Hey there, board game enthusiasts! Are you excited to dive deeper into the world of beautiful games that may fall short in terms of gameplay? This time, we’re not just skimming the surface. We’ll be examining the ins and outs of expectations, dissecting the possible logical fallacies in our previous discussion, and offering even more tips and examples to help you strike the perfect balance between art and play. So, buckle up and let’s go!

Expectations: The Shiny Object Syndrome

Let’s start by exploring why we sometimes fall for games with fantastic artwork but end up feeling let down by the gameplay. It’s important to understand that our brains are wired to be drawn to beautiful things. This phenomenon, known as the “shiny object syndrome,” can cause us to be lured in by games with exceptional artwork, creating high expectations that may not always be met.

When the artwork is outstanding, it’s easy to assume that the gameplay will be equally fantastic. We might even expect these games to provide a more immersive, thematic experience. However, when the gameplay doesn’t live up to these expectations, it can leave players feeling disappointed and wondering where they went wrong.

A Closer Look at Scythe: A Double-Edged Sword


Previously, we used Scythe as an example of a game that has excellent artwork but might fall short for some players in terms of gameplay. Although we mistakenly included it in the list of games with great artwork and gameplay, it is important to address this inconsistency and examine the game more closely.

Scythe is widely praised for its artwork by Jakub Rozalski, featuring stunning visuals and components. However, some players argue that the gameplay is not as thematic or immersive as the artwork suggests. This discrepancy can lead to disappointment, as it’s more of a Euro-style game focused on resource management and points rather than exploring and combat.

While Scythe’s gameplay has been well-received by many players, it’s essential to recognize that it’s not for everyone. The key takeaway here is that a game’s artwork can sometimes create expectations that may not be met by the gameplay, leading to mixed experiences.

Other Games with the Artwork-Gameplay Dissonance

Scythe isn’t the only game that has faced criticism for the dissonance between its artwork and gameplay. Let’s take a closer look at some other games that have experienced similar issues:

  1. Ankh: Gods of Egypt – This game boasts incredible artwork and detailed miniatures that depict ancient Egyptian gods in a battle for supremacy. However, some players feel that the gameplay lacks depth and fails to deliver a truly thematic experience.
  2. Rococo Deluxe Edition – This game features an opulent art style and luxurious components that immerse players in the world of 18th-century fashion design. Despite this, some players argue that the gameplay can be repetitive and fails to live up to the expectations created by the artwork.
  3. Everdell – Everdell has an enchanting theme and beautiful artwork that transports players to a whimsical woodland world. However, some players have found the gameplay to be underwhelming and lacking in originality.

Avoid Being Dazzled: Tips for Discerning Gamers

It’s easy to fall for the shiny objects, but to ensure you’re making smart choices when it comes to board games, consider these tips:

  1. Do your research: Don’t rely solely on the artwork when making a decision about a game. Read reviews, watch playthroughs, and ask for recommendations from fellow gamers to get a comprehensive understanding of the game’s mechanics and overall experience.
  2. Play before you buy: If possible, try a game before purchasing it. This can give you a hands-on feel for the gameplay and help you determine if it’s a good fit for you and your gaming group. Look for local board game cafes, conventions, or game nights where you can try games before committing to a purchase.
  3. Manage your expectations: It’s important to recognize that just because a game has fantastic artwork, it doesn’t necessarily guarantee a thematic or immersive experience. Be open-minded and focus on the gameplay itself, rather than just the visuals.
  4. Consider gameplay mechanics and themes: When choosing a game, consider the mechanics and themes that you and your gaming group enjoy the most. This will help you find games that not only have great artwork but also offer engaging and enjoyable gameplay.
  5. Don’t be swayed by hype: Sometimes, games with exceptional artwork receive a lot of attention and hype, but this doesn’t always translate to a satisfying gaming experience. Be cautious of falling for the hype, and take the time to consider whether a game is right for you.

Examples of Games with Balanced Artwork and Gameplay

Thrilling Game Moments

Now that we’ve discussed some games that may fall short in terms of gameplay, let’s look at some examples of games that strike a great balance between artwork and gameplay:

  1. Root: Root features a unique, hand-drawn art style and an engaging asymmetrical gameplay that keeps players invested in the game. The artwork perfectly complements the woodland theme and helps to create an immersive experience.
  2. Wingspan: Wingspan boasts beautiful illustrations of birds and a gameplay that is both educational and engaging. The game has received widespread acclaim for its harmonious blend of artwork and gameplay, providing a satisfying experience for players.
  3. Azul: Azul is a visually striking game with vibrant colors and intricate patterns, perfectly capturing the essence of Moorish art. The gameplay is simple yet deep, offering a satisfying experience that keeps players coming back for more.
  4. Spirit Island: With its striking artwork and cooperative gameplay that encourages strategic thinking, Spirit Island offers a perfect balance between visuals and mechanics. The game’s theme of defending an island from invaders is well-supported by the artwork, creating an immersive experience.
  5. Brass: Birmingham: This game combines detailed, atmospheric artwork with strategic gameplay that has players building and maintaining an industrial empire in 19th-century England. The artwork complements the game’s theme and enhances the overall experience.

Conclusion: Striking the Perfect Balance

The world of board games is vast and diverse, with many games featuring fantastic artwork that can draw players in. However, it’s essential to remember that great artwork alone doesn’t guarantee a satisfying gaming experience. By being aware of the potential pitfalls of misleading artwork and following the tips provided in this article, players can make informed decisions about which games to add to their collections and ultimately enjoy their time spent playing board games to the fullest.

As you continue your journey through the world of board games, remember to take the time to appreciate the stunning artwork and production values while also focusing on the gameplay itself. After all, it’s the perfect balance between art and play that will provide you with the most enjoyable experiences.

So, whether you’re searching for games with the best artwork, like Arkham Horror, Vast, or Dominion, or games that strike a balance between visuals and gameplay, like Root, Wingspan, Azul, Spirit Island, or Brass: Birmingham, be sure to keep these factors in mind. Happy gaming!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *